McCauley Honorary | Jared Rothstein, "Surfing, Sharks, & The Limits of Reason"

Center for Mind, Brain, and Culture

Jared Rothstein | Philosophy, Daytona State University
"Surfing, Sharks, & The Limits of Reason"

Based on personal experience surfing in the “Shark Bite Capital of the World” (Volusia County, Florida) and interdisciplinary research from the fields of behavioral economics, neuropsychology, and philosophy of mind, the author rejects the traditional Rationalist view that ‘future discounting’ is always unreasonable. He argues, on the contrary, that our natural tendency to opt for immediate rewards in the present can be rational, depending on the values and passions of the individual in question. Emotionally laden decisions are not inherently illogical; and when it comes to future discounting dilemmas, reason can furnish neither universal solutions that would apply to everyone nor certainty in advance. Rather, vexing problems of this type require leaps of probabilistic judgment—a major element of surfing—since we can never know exactly what the future holds.

If you would like to become an AFFILIATE of the Center, please let us know.

Follow along with us on Instagram | Threads | Facebook